
Two people sit on the couch together every night. One remembers it as time spent together. The other remembers looking up from a screen and still feeling alone. They can agree on where they were and what they did, yet disagree about something that matters to both of them: whether they connected.
My guest on episode 474 is Dr. Yael Schonbrun, a clinical psychologist, couples therapist, and author of Why Don’t You Understand Me? The Surprising Science Behind Connecting in a World of Missed Signals. We begin with a distinction at the heart of her book. Communication happens between people. Understanding takes shape within each person, as we decide what to notice and make sense of it through our own experience. Even a clear message can land differently than we intended.
One question I wanted to explore was what better understanding actually changes. If someone’s explanation of their intentions repeatedly diverges from their behavior, asking about the gap may reveal something you hadn’t considered. It can also help you make a more informed decision about how much to rely on that person. In either case, you have learned something you couldn’t have learned by guessing at their motives.
We also discuss how understanding can change the options in front of us. If two people are arguing about whether they need a table, finding out that one of them just wants a flat surface to work on can open up a solution neither person was considering. Sometimes the underlying difference remains. Yael explains why recognizing that two people want different things can still help them make a better decision about their relationship.
Later, we look at generosity through a similar lens. We feel the effort that goes into our own contributions, while we often see only the visible results of someone else’s. That gap helps explain why both people can feel they’re giving more. We talk about when offering a little extra goodwill can help, and when continuing to press for understanding starts to make it harder for either person to listen.
In this episode
- Why two people can interpret the same interaction differently, even when they can watch it back
- How to help someone feel understood while leaving room to question their interpretation
- What people can investigate together when they want different outcomes
- How Yael thinks about the benefits and costs of self-doubt
- What it looks like to step away from a conversation while still appreciating where the other person is coming from

Podcast: Play in new window | Download